Anatomy of a Misfit by Andrea Portes

Posted February 22, 2018 by Amber in Reviews / 0 Comments

Divider
Anatomy of a Misfit by Andrea Portes

Anatomy of a Misfit by Andrea Portes

Digital Audiobook narrated by Caitlin Davies

Published by Harper Children’s on September 2nd 2014
Genres: Contemporary, Fiction, Realistic Fiction, Romance, Young Adult
Length: 336 pages or 6 hours, 10 minutes
Source: Overdrive

GoodreadsAmazonBarnes & NobleBook DepositoryIndieBound

one-star

This emotional, hilarious, devastating, and ultimately triumphant YA debut, based on actual events, recounts one girl’s rejection of her high school’s hierarchy—and her discovery of her true self in the face of tragedy.

Fall’s buzzed-about, in-house favorite.

Outside, Anika Dragomir is all lip gloss and blond hair—the third most popular girl in school. Inside, she’s a freak: a mix of dark thoughts, diabolical plots, and, if local chatter is to be believed, vampire DNA (after all, her father is Romanian). But she keeps it under wraps to maintain her social position. One step out of line and Becky Vilhauer, first most popular girl in school, will make her life hell. So when former loner Logan McDonough shows up one September hotter, smarter, and more mysterious than ever, Anika knows she can’t get involved. It would be insane to throw away her social safety for a nerd. So what if that nerd is now a black-leather-jacket-wearing dreamboat, and his loner status is clearly the result of his troubled home life? Who cares if the right girl could help him with all that, maybe even save him from it? Who needs him when Jared Kline, the bad boy every girl dreams of, is asking her on dates? Who?

Anatomy of a Misfit is Mean Girls meets The Perks of Being a Wallflower, and Anika’s hilariously deadpan delivery will appeal to readers for its honesty and depth. The so-sad-it’s-funny high school setting will pull readers in, but when the story’s dark foreboding gradually takes over, the devastating penultimate tragedy hits like a punch to the gut. Readers will ride the highs and lows alongside funny, flawed Anika — from laughter to tears, and everything in between.


I know that this is about a romance and a boy and a tragic ending, but I cannot move past the slurs.

I believe people with influence have the responsibility to encourage a community of respect.  If this was a book about how racist a place can be, how homophobic a place can be, how sexist a place could be… it would be different.  There would be a lesson buried.  But it isn’t.

How does having a character who calls a character “negro”, having that POC character steal, and justifying it through having that same racist character say “some stereotypes exist for a reason” add to the story?

How does having one character refer to a mean girl as the c-word add to the story?

How does the slut shaming add to the story?  Stealing Vicodin and drugging her boss?

I can keep going.  I mean, the main character has a Romanian background, and she disrespects her own culture by calling her father “Count Chocula”.  Her best friend’s mother is moderately religious and is constantly referred to as “totally insane”.  Every page has something.

Is the author trying to portray that small towns are terrible, inhuman places to live?  Okay, well let me tell you about my small town.

My town has 23,000 residents.  Lincoln, Nebraska (where Anatomy of a Misfit takes place) has a population of 280,000 residents.  So I think I have a better picture of a small town.

Growing up in the 90s, I remember one African-American in my school.  We had three Wiccans and two lesbians and one gay that I knew of.  Two or three kids of Asian decent.  One Indian family, two Greek families.  The rest of us?  Caucasian as f***.  Never ONCE did I witness an incident of racism, sexism, or homophobia among my peers.  We loved the variety of religion in our school, having whole days where we’d bring in Tibetan monks (for example) and learn about them.

Does racism, sexism, homophobia, and religious intolerance exist in my community?  I’m sure it does!  Last year, one of our residents was in the news as a white supremacist.  And the community, as a whole, as ashamed.  Outraged.  Twice as many people showed up to the protests and rallies.  He was ostracized.

My point in sharing this is that there is no way this whole town can be a cesspool of intolerance, the way it is described.  The author has said that it is a reflection of her childhood.  Did she really experience this level of hatred?  Or is it a reflection of her own beliefs?  I don’t even know.  But listening to this, at points, made me feel physically ill.

Oh my gosh, let’s think of other things that are seriously wrong?  Anika doesn’t understand the difference between a respectful person and a violent one.  Logan is a “bad boy” stereotype.  Shelly is a bimbo stereotype.  Every character is actually a stereotype.  The scene where the family tries to hand out to the POC because they feel bad for her because she’s a POC.  How the mom marries an “ogre” because she doesn’t know better and needs to care for her children.

How the narrator speaks in the worst accents for all the non-white characters.

How the story adds guilt to people in unhealthy relationships.  Emotionally abusive relationships are never okay.

I can’t get past all this.  It could have been a sad, tragic story about a boy in an abusive home, and a devastating ending.  That would have been enough.  In fact, a kind and loving town doing such a thing would have been a more powerful story.  But, instead, Anatomy of a Misfit just teaches its readers that Nebraska is filled with white supremacists and should be burned.

Oh, and apparently it’s appropriate to use a memorial service to out a bully and get revenge.

Oh stop.  Please stop.

Do stories like this need to be told?  Yes!  Yes, it needs to be out there so people understand and know the signs and do something before the real world has an ending like this.

But not like this.

Divider
The Breakdown
Plot
one-half-stars
Characters
zero-stars
Writing
half-star
Pacing
three-half-stars
Setting
zero-stars
Narrator
two-stars
Personal Enjoyment
zero-stars
Overall: one-star
Divider


Tags:

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.