Book Review: The Book of Three by Lloyd Alexander

The Book of Three by Lloyd Alexander

Posted April 14, 2019 by Amber in Reviews / 4 Comments

Divider
The Book of Three

The Book of Three

by Lloyd Alexander

Series: The Chronicles of Prydain #1
Publisher: Henry Holt & Co. on March 12, 1964
Genre: Fantasy
Target Age Group: Middle Grade
Content Warnings: Misogyny, Sexism

Rating: ★★★

Check out this book on Goodreads or buy the book at Bookshop.org

Taran wanted to be a hero, and looking after a pig wasn't exactly heroic, even though Hen Wen was an oracular pig. But the day that Hen Wen vanished, Taran was led into an enchanting and perilous world. With his band of followers, he confronted the Horned King and his terrible Cauldron-Born. These were the forces of evil, and only Hen Wen knew the secret of keeping the kingdom of Prydain safe from them. But who would find her first?


So much of me wanted to roll my eyes at the common tropes and general unoriginality in The Book of Three… but then I had to remind myself:  this book was first published in 1964.  A lot of the tired tropes in The Book of Three were fresh and new 54 years ago.  For all the fantasy I read, I rarely stumble across classic epic fantasy I haven’t read before.  That makes this a bit complicated to review.

So.  Taking a step back from modern fantasy.  Taking a step back from the diverse themes and relationships woven into a lot of the YA we see now… lets look at The Book of Three objectively in its time.

First of all, for 1964, I am impressed by the gender roles.  Any diversity is lovely, and Princess Eilonwy is properly brave and clever.  I appreciate the bits where she tells off the men for treating her like a helpless child just because she’s a girl (or perhaps because she’s a princess? … regardless…).

I know a very little of Celtic mythology, so the reference to Taliesin made me smile.  The Book of Three is inspired by Welsh mythology, and honestly?  If you’re going to have a Western European-inspired epic fantasy… this is how you do it.  Don’t just follow the Arthurian tropes – delve into the mythos and embrace it.  Do nothing halfway.  For all the Western European-esque fantasies, so few of them actually do the research and incorporate all aspects of that aesthetic choice.  So this was great.

The plot drags a little for my taste.  The pacing isn’t bad, although it feels more like YA than childrens or MG.  Where the plot often feels like it’s not going anywhere, the scenes pass really quickly, and the whole book is left a little unbalanced.  There are several sections in here where other characters go off and have adventures, then they come back and tell Taran all about it.  That left a little excitement to be desired.

Okay, we also need to talk about this whole “assistant pig keeper” thing.  Our hero, Taran, is not a hero in the traditional sense.  Taran is an Assistant Pig Keeper.  Don’t worry though.  If you tuned out somewhere near the beginning of the novel, you’re be reminded every few pages.  At first, the repetition of this fact was kind of amusing and felt like gentle teasing, but after a while it started get annoying.  Not to mention a little condescending to poor Taran?  On one hand I see the whole aspect of coming from humble beginnings and surpassing your challenges, but egats, yes, I know he’s an Assistant Pig Keeper!

All in all, this was a light book and I’d say even in the modern era it’s a good introduction to epic fantasy for younger readers.  For seasoned veterans of the genre, it’s not the peak of the genre, but I do respect how fantastic it surely was in its time.  I had this feeling as I listened that I’d read this before, a very long time ago.  Something about Eilonwy and her glowing bauble struck a cord….  It wouldn’t surprise me – Lloyd Alexander’s Time Cat was one of my favorite books growing up and I still have my old battered copy on my shelf.  I would continue reading the series, mostly for this strong nostalgic feeling.  I really do think young readers would like this one, and it would be a good book to introduce this type of fantasy.

Setting

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Characters

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Pacing

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Personal Enjoyment

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Plot

Rating: 2 out of 5.

Writing

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Narrator

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

No Bad Apples Here!

According to my research, this author has not written any problematic books, does not have a problematic history wherein they have (through intention or ignorance) insulted or hurt marginalized communities, and does not use their platform to speak out in hate against others, nor have they performed any known damaging or illegal acts. For now, I’m very pleased to encourage you to support this author and their works!

send me your thoughts

What was the first fantasy book you remember reading?

Mine was Wild Magic by Tamora Pierce… though now I’m wondering if maybe I’d read The Chronicles of Prydain even younger…

Share with me in the comments!

stay magical amber

Instagram | Twitter | Goodreads | Bloglovin’ | LibraryThing | The StoryGraph | Twitch

Other Books by Lloyd Alexander

2 books found

★★★★★

★★★


Tags:

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 responses to “The Book of Three by Lloyd Alexander

  1. If it feels like this one ends up unbalanced, it might be because there’s a lot to come in the next few books. Taran and company hardly get to catch their breath from here on out. It does seem to drag sometimes though, you’re right.

    • Amber

      It definitely could be that. I think introductory novels tend to drag a little more than their sequels on the basis of introducing the world and the characters. I’m going to reach into the rest of the world, for sure!

  2. I don’t really remember it, but I definitely read this one when I was younger… I never bothered to finish the series, but I think I enjoyed it well enough.

    I’ve been reading fantasy for literally as long as I can remember, so I don’t really know what the first one I read was, but I have a lot of fond memories of Edward Eager books, and of Tamora Pierce books (especially Circle of Magic, the others came a bit later).

    • Amber

      I remember the Circle of Magic most of Tamora Pierce’s books, too! Though I know The Immortals was my first.

      I’m not familiar with Edgar Eager, but I just looked up the series and all the covers remind me of Roald Dahl. I think I would have loved those when I was younger! You have impeccable taste, as always. 😉